Unfair Dismissal Lawyers - Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers Unfair Dismissal Lawyers | Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers

UNFAIR DISMISSAL CLAIM LAWYERS

If you have recently been terminated from your job and believe that your dismissal was harsh, unjust, or unreasonable, seeking expert legal advice is crucial. Unfair dismissal is a complex area of employment law, and navigating it on your own can be daunting. At Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers, our experienced team is dedicated to protecting your rights under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). We will assess your situation to determine if your dismissal was unlawful and guide you through the process of making a claim. Whether your dismissal was harsh, unjust, or unreasonable, or if your redundancy was not genuine, we are here to ensure you receive the justice you deserve. Contact Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers today for a confidential consultation to discuss your case and explore your legal options.

Unfair Dismissal Lawyers Sydney Employment Lawyers

Unfair Dismissal Claims For Employees

We Understand

At Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers, we understand that the loss of employment can be a distressing and challenging experience. Particularly when it occurs under circumstances that may be deemed unfair or unjust. Unfair dismissal can have significant ramifications not only on your career but also on your financial stability and emotional well-being. Our team of dedicated and experienced employment lawyers is committed to providing you with the legal support and guidance you need during such difficult times.

What is Unfair Dismissal?

Unfair dismissal occurs when an employee is dismissed from their job in a harsh, unjust, or unreasonable manner. Under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), employees have the right to challenge the fairness of their dismissal if they believe it was not warranted or if due process was not followed. At Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers, we assist employees in navigating the complexities of unfair dismissal claims, ensuring their rights are protected and that they receive the justice they deserve.

Understanding Your Rights

When facing dismissal, it's crucial to understand your rights under Australian employment law. Employees may be eligible to lodge an unfair dismissal claim if they meet the following criteria:

1. They have completed the minimum employment period (typically six months, or 12 months for small businesses with fewer than 15 employees).

2. They are covered by the national workplace relations system.

3. Their dismissal was not due to genuine redundancy.

Our legal team at Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers will help you determine if you qualify to file an unfair dismissal claim and guide you through each step of the process.

The Process of Making an Unfair Dismissal Claim

The process of making an unfair dismissal claim involves several key stages:

1. Filing a Claim: The first step is to lodge your claim with the Fair Work Commission within 21 days of your dismissal. Our solicitors will ensure your claim is filed accurately and promptly, providing all necessary documentation to support your case.

2. Conciliation: The Fair Work Commission may arrange a conciliation conference between you and your employer to resolve the dispute amicably. During this informal process, our solicitors will represent your interests, aiming to reach a fair settlement without the need for a formal hearing.

3. Formal Hearing: If conciliation fails to resolve the matter, the case may proceed to a formal hearing before the Fair Work Commission. Our experienced solicitors will present a compelling case on your behalf, advocating for a favourable outcome.

4. Outcome: If the Fair Work Commission finds that your dismissal was unfair, it may order remedies such as reinstatement to your former position or compensation for lost wages and other damages.

Criteria for Considering Harshness, Unjustness, or Unreasonableness in Unfair Dismissal Claims

When an employee lodges an unfair dismissal claim, the Fair Work Commission (FWC) must assess whether the dismissal was harsh, unjust, or unreasonable. To make this determination, the FWC considers specific criteria outlined in Section 387 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). Understanding these criteria is essential for both employees and employers involved in unfair dismissal cases, as they form the foundation upon which the fairness of a dismissal is judged.

1. Valid Reason for Dismissal Related to Capacity or Conduct
One of the first considerations for the FWC is whether there was a valid reason for the dismissal, directly related to the employee's capacity or conduct. This criterion examines whether the employee's actions or job performance genuinely warranted termination. A valid reason might include poor job performance, misconduct, or behaviour that affects the safety and welfare of other employees. For instance, if an employee consistently fails to meet performance standards despite adequate support and training, or engages in behaviour that endangers others, these could constitute valid reasons for dismissal.

However, it is not enough for an employer to merely assert that there was a valid reason. The FWC will closely scrutinise the evidence presented, considering whether the reason was substantial and genuine, and whether it was sufficiently serious to justify dismissal.

2. Notification of the Reason for Dismissal
The FWC also considers whether the employee was notified of the reason for their dismissal. This criterion is crucial as it relates to the procedural fairness of the dismissal process. An employee must be informed of the specific reasons for their dismissal in a clear and timely manner. This allows the employee to understand the grounds on which the employer has based the decision to terminate their employment. Failure to provide such notification can render the dismissal unfair, regardless of the validity of the reason itself.

3. Opportunity to Respond
In conjunction with being notified of the reason for dismissal, the employee must be given a fair opportunity to respond. This means the employee should be allowed to explain or defend themselves against the allegations or performance issues raised by the employer. The FWC will examine whether the employee was given sufficient time and a proper platform to present their case. If an employer dismisses an employee without giving them a chance to address the issues, this could be considered procedurally unfair, potentially leading to a finding of unfair dismissal.

4. Refusal to Allow a Support Person
Another critical aspect considered by the FWC is whether the employer unreasonably refused the employee's request to have a support person present during discussions related to their dismissal. A support person can provide emotional assistance, help the employee articulate their responses, and ensure the process is conducted fairly. The absence of a support person, especially if unreasonably refused by the employer, can influence the FWC's assessment of the fairness of the dismissal process.

5. Warnings About Unsatisfactory Performance
If the dismissal was related to unsatisfactory performance, the FWC will assess whether the employee had been warned about their performance issues before the dismissal. It is generally expected that employees be given formal warnings and an opportunity to improve before being dismissed for poor performance. A lack of prior warnings or a failure to give the employee a reasonable chance to improve can weigh heavily against the employer in an unfair dismissal claim.

6. Size of the Employer's Enterprise
The size of the employer's enterprise is another factor that the FWC takes into account. Smaller businesses may not have the same resources or formal procedures as larger organisations. The FWC recognises that in smaller enterprises, the dismissal process might not be as formalised due to the lack of dedicated human resource departments or the need for more streamlined operations. However, this does not absolve employers of the responsibility to act fairly; rather, it is a contextual factor that may influence the procedural aspects of the dismissal.

7. Absence of Dedicated Human Resource Management Specialists
Related to the size of the enterprise, the FWC also considers whether the employer has access to dedicated human resource management specialists or expertise. In smaller businesses without HR specialists, there might be less formality in the dismissal process. The FWC acknowledges this reality but will still expect that basic principles of fairness and natural justice are adhered to. Employers must take reasonable steps to ensure that the dismissal process is conducted fairly, even if they lack formal HR resources.

8. Any Other Relevant Matters
Finally, the FWC has the discretion to consider any other matters it deems relevant to the case. This is a broad, catch-all criterion that allows the FWC to take into account factors that might not be explicitly listed but are nonetheless pertinent to the fairness of the dismissal. For instance, the FWC might consider the employee’s length of service, the personal circumstances of the employee, or any mitigating factors that could influence the fairness of the dismissal.

Why Choose Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers?

Choosing the right legal representation is crucial when pursuing an unfair dismissal claim. At Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers, we bring a wealth of experience and a commitment to excellence in everything we do. Our solicitors are not just legal experts; they are passionate advocates for justice who are dedicated to helping employees navigate the often confusing and intimidating world of employment law.

We understand that every unfair dismissal case is unique, with its own set of facts, challenges, and emotions. That’s why we take a personalised approach to each case, taking the time to understand your individual circumstances, your goals, and your concerns. We pride ourselves on providing clear, practical advice that is tailored to your specific situation. Whether you’re seeking reinstatement, compensation, or simply closure, we will work tirelessly to achieve the best possible outcome for you.

Our firm’s reputation is built on a foundation of trust, integrity, and a relentless pursuit of justice. We have successfully represented clients in a wide range of unfair dismissal cases, from straightforward disputes to highly complex litigation. Our track record speaks for itself, and we are proud of the positive outcomes we have achieved for our clients.

Our Commitment to You

At Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers, we recognise that dealing with an unfair dismissal can be one of the most stressful experiences of your life. The uncertainty, the financial strain, and the emotional toll can be overwhelming. That’s why we are committed to providing you with not just legal representation, but also the support and reassurance you need during this challenging time.

We approach every case with the care and attention it deserves, taking the time to listen to your story and understand your needs. Our goal is to provide you with a clear path forward, guiding you through the legal process with empathy and professionalism. We are committed to fighting for your rights and ensuring that justice is done.

Unfair Dismissal Lawyers for Employers

Defending Unfair Dismissal Claims For Employers

We Understand

At Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers, we understand that managing a workforce involves complex decisions, including, at times, the difficult decision to terminate an employee. While employers have the right to dismiss employees who fail to meet performance standards or who engage in misconduct, the process must be handled with great care to avoid unfair dismissal claims under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). Our team is here to guide you through this process, ensuring that your business remains compliant with Australian employment laws while protecting your interests.

Understanding Unfair Dismissal from an Employer’s Perspective

Unfair dismissal claims can pose a significant risk to businesses, both in terms of legal costs and the potential for reputational damage. The Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) provides employees with the right to challenge their dismissal if they believe it was harsh, unjust, or unreasonable. For employers, this means that any termination must be carefully justified and procedurally fair to withstand scrutiny.

To protect your business, it is essential to understand the grounds on which an employee might bring an unfair dismissal claim, and how to mitigate these risks effectively.

Defending Against Unfair Dismissal Claims

At Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers, we provide comprehensive legal support to employers facing unfair dismissal claims. Our services include advising on the validity of dismissals, representing employers in negotiations and hearings, and helping to implement best practices in workforce management. Below are some key aspects of our defence services:

1. Valid Reason for Dismissal

One of the most critical elements in defending an unfair dismissal claim is demonstrating that there was a valid reason for the termination. This reason must be sound, defensible, and related to the employee’s conduct or capacity. Examples of valid reasons include:

A. Poor Performance: When an employee consistently fails to meet performance standards, despite being given adequate support and opportunities to improve.

B. Misconduct: Serious breaches of workplace policies, such as theft, harassment, or violence, can justify immediate dismissal.
Redundancy: Genuine redundancy, where the role is no longer required due to operational changes, can also serve as a valid reason for dismissal.

We assist employers in documenting and presenting evidence of the valid reasons for dismissal, ensuring that the decision is well-supported and legally defensible.

2. Procedural Fairness


Even where a valid reason for dismissal exists, the dismissal process must be procedurally fair. Procedural fairness involves several key steps:

A. Notification: The employee must be informed of the reason for dismissal in clear terms.

B. Opportunity to Respond: The employee must be given a chance to respond to the allegations or performance issues before a final decision is made.

C. Investigation: Any allegations of misconduct should be thoroughly investigated, and the employee should be given an opportunity to explain their side of the story.

D. Support Person: Employers should not unreasonably refuse an employee’s request to have a support person present during discussions about their dismissal.

Failing to adhere to these procedural requirements can result in a dismissal being deemed unfair, regardless of the underlying reasons. Our legal team provides expert guidance on conducting fair and compliant dismissal procedures, tailored to the specific circumstances of your business.

3. Small Business Exemptions

Small businesses (those with fewer than 15 employees) are subject to different rules under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). For example, they are exempt from certain unfair dismissal claims provided that the dismissal is not harsh, unjust, or unreasonable. However, even small businesses must comply with the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code, which outlines the steps that must be taken to ensure a fair dismissal.

Our lawyers are experienced in advising small business clients on how to comply with these special provisions, reducing the risk of unfair dismissal claims while managing dismissals effectively.

4. Genuine Redundancy

When dismissing an employee due to redundancy, it is vital to ensure that the redundancy is genuine. This means that the role must no longer be required, and the employer must have made reasonable efforts to redeploy the employee within the organisation. If these criteria are met, the dismissal cannot be classified as unfair.

Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers assists employers in navigating the complexities of redundancy, ensuring that the process is handled lawfully and with sensitivity to minimise disruption to the business.

5. Addressing Employee Misconduct

Dismissing an employee for serious misconduct requires careful consideration and adherence to legal requirements. Misconduct that justifies dismissal includes serious breaches such as theft, fraud, or endangering the safety of others. To defend against an unfair dismissal claim based on misconduct, the employer must show that the misconduct was severe enough to warrant termination and that proper procedures were followed.

Our team provides robust support in managing cases of employee misconduct, from conducting internal investigations to representing employers in any subsequent legal proceedings.

Proactive Measures to Prevent Unfair Dismissal Claims

Beyond defending against claims, Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers offers strategic advice on how to proactively manage your workforce to prevent unfair dismissal claims from arising. This includes:

1. Implementing Clear Employment Policies: Well-drafted policies can help set expectations for employee behaviour and performance, providing a strong foundation for managing dismissals.

2. Regular Performance Reviews: Conducting regular performance reviews and providing feedback helps ensure that any issues are identified and addressed before they escalate to the point of dismissal.

3. Training for Managers: Providing training for managers on fair dismissal procedures and the legal requirements under the Fair Work Act can help reduce the risk of unfair dismissal claims.

Our Commitment to You

At Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers, we recognise that dealing with an unfair dismissal can be one of the most stressful experiences of your life. The uncertainty, the financial strain, and the emotional toll can be overwhelming. That’s why we are committed to providing you with not just legal representation, but also the support and reassurance you need during this challenging time.

We approach every case with the care and attention it deserves, taking the time to listen to your story and understand your needs. Our goal is to provide you with a clear path forward, guiding you through the legal process with empathy and professionalism. We are committed to fighting for your rights and ensuring that justice is done.

Contact Form

Fill out the form below to receive a same day free consultation call

Unfair Dismissal Lawyers For Employees and Employers

About us

At Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers, we make it our mission to uphold the integrity of Australia's workplace landscape. Our dedicated team strives to ensure that every workplace is a safe and just environment for all. Let our passion for employment law guide you towards a brighter future.

Trust the experts at Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers to navigate the complexities of workplace laws with precision and care. Your peace of mind is our priority, and together, we can build a stronger, fairer workplace for everyone.

Why us?

1. Free

Initial call to obtain guidance on your prospects of success and an overview of what work is involved in your matter

2. Easy

Straightforward and simple legal advice that cuts through the legal jargon and provides clear, actionable solutions

3. Dynamic

Advice and support provided to you instantly. Delay can cause complications; act now for prompt solutions

Contact Us

Get in touch
  • Phone: +61 0450 491 637
  • Email: ph@benthamlegal.com.au

  • Address:
  • Unit 29/15 Valediction Road, Kings Park NSW 2148
  • Working hours:
  • 8:00AM - 7:30PM

Additional Services

For assistance from Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers with other areas of employment law, click on the links below or book a free initial call
Unfair Dismissal

Bentham Lawyers excel in unfair, unlawful, and wrongful dismissal cases for employers and employees. Competitive rates. See how we can help.

bullying and harassment lawyers
Bullying and Harassment

Bentham Lawyers offer clear, quick advice on bullying, harassment, workplace discrimination and equal opportunity. See how we can help.

fair work pay advice modern awards
Employment and Fair Work Advice

Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers offer expert employment and Fair Work advice at competitive rates. See how we can help.

enterprise agreement lawyers
Enterprise Agreements

We expertly negotiate enterprise agreements tailored to your needs, ensuring compliance and optimal outcomes for your business.

nes lawyers pay and entitlements
Award Interpretation

Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers clarifies award terms, ensuring your business operations align with legal requirements.

post employment restraint lawyers
Contract Disputes

Mobirise is an easy website builder. Just drop site elements to your page, add content and style it to look the way you like.

general protections lawyers
General Protections Disputes

We defend your rights in general protections disputes, offering strategic solutions to safeguard your workplace.

deed of release lawyers
Deed of Release Preparation

We draft or negotiate Deed of Release agreements, ensuring clear terms that protect your legal and financial interests.

Got Questions?

Only if you have engaged in serious misconduct.

Serious misconduct is a severe breach of contract that justifies immediate dismissal without notice. This type of behavior significantly impacts the business or poses serious risks to the safety and well-being of colleagues.

Under typical conditions, an employer is required to provide written notice of termination, including the termination date, and may ask the employee to work through the notice period or, alternatively, provide payment in lieu of notice. However, when serious misconduct is involved, the employer is entitled to terminate the employment relationship immediately, bypassing the usual notice requirements.

Examples of serious misconduct include:

1. Theft or Fraud: Misappropriation of company property or engaging in fraudulent activities.

2. Dishonesty: Acts of dishonesty that undermine the trust essential to the employment relationship.

3. Intoxication at Work: Attending work under the influence of drugs or alcohol, which compromises safety or performance.

4. Criminal Conviction: Being convicted of a criminal offence that is incompatible with the employee’s role or duties.

5. Gross Negligence: Reckless disregard for one’s duties, resulting in significant harm or risk to the business.

6. Violent Behaviour: Engaging in physical altercations or threatening colleagues with violence.

7. Disobeying Lawful Directions: Repeatedly failing to comply with lawful and reasonable instructions from the employer.

8. Safety Breaches: Ignoring or violating workplace safety rules, putting oneself or others at risk.

9. Inappropriate Use of Confidential Information: Mishandling or misusing sensitive company data or trade secrets.

It is important to note that while employers have the right to dismiss for serious misconduct, the circumstances must be carefully assessed to ensure that the dismissal is justified. If you have been dismissed for serious misconduct, it is prudent to seek expert legal advice. A lawyer can help determine whether your dismissal was handled lawfully and explore any potential grounds for challenging the termination through a legal claim.

Unfair dismissal occurs when an employee is terminated in a manner that is harsh, unjust, or unreasonable. Under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), for a dismissal to be considered unfair, it must lack a valid reason related to the employee’s capacity, conduct, or operational requirements of the business. Additionally, the process followed by the employer in effecting the dismissal must have been procedurally fair. This includes providing the employee with an opportunity to respond to any allegations before the decision to dismiss is made. If an employee believes their dismissal was unfair, they may lodge a claim with the Fair Work Commission within 21 days of the dismissal.

To be eligible to make an unfair dismissal claim under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), an employee must meet certain criteria:

1. Minimum Employment Period: The employee must have been employed for at least six months with the employer. For employees of small businesses (fewer than 15 employees), the minimum period is 12 months.

2. Income Threshold: The employee’s annual earnings must not exceed the high-income threshold, unless they are covered by a modern award or enterprise agreement.

3. Employment Status: Certain employees, such as casual employees without a pattern of regular and systematic work or those on fixed-term contracts, may not be eligible to make an unfair dismissal claim.

If these criteria are met, the employee may proceed with an application to the Fair Work Commission to have their case heard.

Employers can defend against an unfair dismissal claim by presenting several key arguments:

1. Valid Reason: The employer can argue that the dismissal was based on a valid reason, such as misconduct, poor performance, redundancy, or breach of contract.

2. Procedural Fairness: The employer may demonstrate that they followed fair procedures in dismissing the employee, including providing notice of the reasons for dismissal, giving the employee an opportunity to respond, and conducting a thorough investigation.

3. Genuine Redundancy: If the dismissal was due to redundancy, the employer can argue that the redundancy was genuine, meaning the job no longer exists and alternative employment was explored but not available.

4. Small Business Fair Dismissal Code: Small businesses (fewer than 15 employees) can rely on the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code as a defence if they adhered to its guidelines when dismissing the employee.

These defences must be substantiated with evidence, and the Fair Work Commission will consider them in the context of the overall fairness of the dismissal.

If the Fair Work Commission determines that an employee has been unfairly dismissed, several remedies may be available:

1. Reinstatement: The employee may be reinstated to their former position or a comparable one within the organisation, with continuity of service and benefits.

2. Compensation: If reinstatement is not feasible or desirable, the Commission may order the employer to pay compensation. Compensation is capped at six months' wages, or half of the high income threshold, and is intended to cover the financial losses resulting from the dismissal.

The remedies are intended to restore the employee to the position they would have been in had the unfair dismissal not occurred, as far as practicable.

Procedural fairness, also known as "natural justice," plays a crucial role in determining whether a dismissal was unfair. For a dismissal to be procedurally fair, the employer must:

1. Provide Notice: The employee must be informed of the reason for their potential dismissal and the evidence supporting it.

2. Opportunity to Respond: The employee must be given a reasonable opportunity to respond to the allegations, including time to prepare a defence or explanation.

3. Impartial Decision-Making: The decision to dismiss must be made by an impartial person or panel, without any bias or pre-determined outcome.

4. Support Person: The employee should be allowed to have a support person present during any meetings or discussions related to the dismissal, especially if the employee requests one.

A failure to adhere to procedural fairness can render a dismissal unfair, even if there was a valid reason for the termination. The Fair Work Commission carefully examines whether these procedural elements were observed when assessing an unfair dismissal claim.

Unfair Dismissal Lawyers Sydney

Our experienced lawyers at Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers can help you prepare and represent you in unfair dismissal cases before the Fair Work Commission.

Unfair Dismissal Lawyers: Expert Representation and Application Preparation