Unfair Dismissal Claims

Unfair dismissal is a serious issue with substantial impacts on both employees and employers. When employment is terminated without valid reason or proper process, understanding your legal rights is crucial. Addressing unfair dismissal involves scrutinising employment contracts, company policies, and the termination process. For effective representation and to safeguard your rights, prompt expert advice is essential. Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers are here to provide the expert guidance you need. Contact us now to ensure your unfair dismissal claim is managed with the urgency and expertise it deserves.

Unfair Dismissal Lawyers Sydney Employment Lawyers

Remedies For Unfair Dismissal

Navigating the complexities of unfair dismissal can be challenging for both employees and employers. In the recent decision of Hampshire v Breakwater Metaland Pty Ltd [2024] FWC 1933, the Fair Work Commission explored the nuanced remedies available for unfair dismissal, focusing on reinstatement and compensation.

Reinstatement: A Complex Remedy

Reinstatement, as a primary remedy for unfair dismissal, aims to return an employee to their former position. However, in the Hampshire case, the Commission found that reinstatement was impractical. The applicant’s role had been filled, and a severe breakdown in the relationship between the employee and employer, exacerbated by ongoing legal disputes and internal conflicts, rendered the employment relationship untenable. The Commission assessed whether a workable level of trust and confidence could be restored and concluded that it could not, highlighting the importance of evaluating the feasibility of reinstatement based on the specific circumstances and the current workplace dynamics.

Compensation: Calculating Fair Compensation

When reinstatement is not viable, compensation becomes the primary remedy. The Fair Work Commission used a structured approach to determine compensation, following the methodology established in Sprigg v Paul’s Licensed Festival Supermarket (1998) 88 IR 21. This involves calculating lost remuneration, deducting earnings since termination, adjusting for contingencies, and applying the legislative cap on compensation. In Hampshire, the Commission found that the applicant would have earned $98,800 had the dismissal not occurred but adjusted this figure to the compensation cap of $49,400 after accounting for earnings post-termination and other relevant factors. This structured approach ensures that compensation is fair and reflects what the employee would have likely received had they not been unfairly dismissed.

Expert Advice and Support

The decision underscores the complexities involved in determining appropriate remedies for unfair dismissal. Whether considering reinstatement or compensation, it is crucial to seek expert legal advice to navigate these challenges effectively. Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers are here to provide comprehensive legal support and guidance in unfair dismissal cases. Contact us to ensure your rights are protected and to receive the expert advice necessary to address your unfair dismissal claim with the urgency it demands.

unfair dismissal lawyers sydney

Understanding Unfair Dismissal: Proof Issues and Employer Burden

Unfair dismissal claims often hinge on complex issues of proof, particularly when an employer alleges that misconduct justified the employee’s termination. In a recent decision, the Fair Work Commission (FWC) addressed these proof issues, highlighting the evidentiary burdens employers must meet. Here’s a summary of the key points from the decision in Weerasekara v Serco Australia Pty Limited [2024] FWC 2462:

Valid Reason for Dismissal

For a dismissal to be considered fair, it must be based on a valid reason related to the employee’s capacity or conduct. The reason must be “sound, defensible or well founded” and not “capricious, fanciful, spiteful or prejudiced.” The Commission’s role is not to substitute its own judgment for that of the employer but to ensure that the reason for dismissal meets these standards.

Burden of Proof

In cases of alleged misconduct, the employer bears the burden of proof. It must demonstrate, on the balance of probabilities, that the misconduct occurred. Simply having a reasonable belief that the dismissal was justified is not sufficient. The employer must provide concrete evidence that the alleged conduct took place.

Briginshaw Standard

When serious allegations are involved, the Briginshaw standard applies. This means that the evidence must meet a higher threshold of clarity and certainty. The findings of misconduct should not be based on vague, indefinite, or insufficient evidence. Instead, the evidence must be compelling and robust to justify a dismissal.

This decision underscores the importance for employers to meticulously document and substantiate any claims of misconduct. The burden of proof lies with the employer to provide clear, credible evidence supporting their decision to dismiss an employee.

For expert advice and representation in unfair dismissal matters, contact Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers. Our Sydney-based employment lawyers are here to guide you through the complexities of employment law and ensure your case is handled with the utmost care and expertise.

Contact Form

Fill out the form below to receive a same day free consultation call

About us

At Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers, we make it our mission to uphold the integrity of Australia's workplace landscape. Our dedicated team strives to ensure that every workplace is a safe and just environment for all. Let our passion for employment law guide you towards a brighter future.

Trust the experts at Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers to navigate the complexities of workplace laws with precision and care. Your peace of mind is our priority, and together, we can build a stronger, fairer workplace for everyone.

Why us?

1. Free

Initial call to obtain guidance on your prospects of success and an overview of what work is involved in your matter

2. Easy

Straightforward and simple legal advice that cuts through the legal jargon and provides clear, actionable solutions

3. Dynamic

Advice and support provided to you instantly. Delay can cause complications; act now for prompt solutions

Additional Services

For assistance from Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers with other areas of employment law, click on the links below or book a free initial call
Unfair Dismissal

Bentham Lawyers excel in unfair, unlawful, and wrongful dismissal cases for employers and employees. Competitive rates. See how we can help.

bullying and harassment lawyers
Bullying and Harassment

Bentham Lawyers offer clear, quick advice on bullying, harassment, workplace discrimination and equal opportunity. See how we can help.

fair work pay advice modern awards
Employment and Fair Work Advice

Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers offer expert employment and Fair Work advice at competitive rates. See how we can help.

enterprise agreement lawyers
Enterprise Agreements

We expertly negotiate enterprise agreements tailored to your needs, ensuring compliance and optimal outcomes for your business.

nes lawyers pay and entitlements
Award Interpretation

Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers clarifies award terms, ensuring your business operations align with legal requirements.

post employment restraint lawyers
Contract Disputes

Mobirise is an easy website builder. Just drop site elements to your page, add content and style it to look the way you like.

general protections lawyers
General Protections Disputes

We defend your rights in general protections disputes, offering strategic solutions to safeguard your workplace.

deed of release lawyers
Deed of Release Preparation

We draft or negotiate Deed of Release agreements, ensuring clear terms that protect your legal and financial interests.

Contact Us

Get in touch
  • Phone: +61 0450 491 637
  • Email: ph@benthamlegal.com.au

  • Address:
  • Unit 29/15 Valediction Road, Kings Park NSW 2148
  • Working hours:
  • 8:00AM - 7:30PM

Got Questions?

Unfair dismissal occurs when an employee is terminated from their job in a manner that is harsh, unjust, or unreasonable. This may involve a lack of a valid reason for dismissal, failure to follow proper procedural requirements, or dismissal in retaliation for exercising workplace rights. To determine if a dismissal is unfair, various factors are considered, including the reason for the dismissal and whether proper processes were followed. For personalised advice on whether a dismissal may be considered unfair, contact Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers for expert assistance.

If an employer receives an unfair dismissal claim, they should promptly review the details of the claim and gather all relevant documentation related to the termination. It is essential to assess whether proper procedures were followed and if the dismissal was for a valid reason. Employers should also prepare to engage in conciliation or hearings with the Fair Work Commission if required. For guidance on how to handle an unfair dismissal claim and to ensure compliance with the Fair Work Act, contact Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers for expert advice.

Yes, employees on probationary periods can still claim unfair dismissal. However, there are specific considerations for probationary employees, such as whether the dismissal was based on a valid reason and if proper procedural fairness was observed. Probationary employees must demonstrate that their dismissal was not justified or that it breached the terms of their employment. For advice on unfair dismissal claims during probationary periods, contact Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers to explore your options.

To support an unfair dismissal claim, an employee typically needs to provide evidence such as their employment contract, records of performance reviews, communications related to the dismissal, and any evidence of procedural breaches. Additionally, demonstrating that the dismissal was not for a valid reason or that proper processes were not followed is crucial. For assistance in gathering and presenting the necessary evidence for your claim, contact Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers for expert support.

Employers can minimise the risk of unfair dismissal claims by ensuring they follow proper procedures, including providing clear reasons for termination, adhering to company policies and employment contracts, and offering opportunities for the employee to respond to concerns. Conducting thorough performance reviews and ensuring compliance with relevant laws and regulations are also key. For tailored advice on preventing unfair dismissal claims and implementing best practices, contact Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers for expert guidance.

If an unfair dismissal claim is successful, remedies may include reinstatement to the former position or compensation for lost wages and other entitlements. The Fair Work Commission will consider factors such as the impact of reinstatement on workplace dynamics and the financial losses suffered by the employee. Compensation calculations involve assessing lost remuneration, deducting any earnings since termination, and applying statutory caps. For detailed advice on the remedies available and how to pursue them, contact Bentham Sydney Employment Lawyers for expert legal assistance.